ISSUES WITH CHOATES WARRANTY

Joined
Feb 22, 2022
Messages
46
Reaction score
5
Location
Missouri
Anyone have experience with Choates Engineering? Particularly with a warranty issue.

So here is the story:
I bought a Choates Engineering 6.4 Workhorse long block back in March 2022. Had it shipped to my shop in Arizona to be installed. At the time my truck ha 299k miles. I drove the truck for about 40k miles and in a relative short time (6 months). Then it started making a sound like a rod knock one morning and smoking pretty badly. So i took a video and called Choates about this. they requested the video, so I emailed it to them. They (Leo and Cass) instructed me to drain the oil and measure it, so i did. No issues to be found there. well then on a short test rive the engine stalled while running and wouldn't restart. It through a cam sync code, i figured it was just a sensor, so i replaced it. No changes to my non running condition. So, I called them up again and said hey something is really wrong and that i believe it to be internal. They then tell me to have the engine removed locally and ship the engine back to them, hoping that i would incur the labor cost for that. I told them no, I will ship the while truck to you.

The truck shipped to them in Tennessee in the beginning of October. They tell me they have a backlog and they would get it looked at in about 2 weeks. Okay, so i call after a couple weeks for an update. Leo, tells me that they have been really busy but they will get to it...Okay? Another week goes by, I call Leo again. He tells me that they have my truck torn apart and the engine apart. They discovered the block is cracked, i need a new block. I then ask the question about is this going to covered under the warranty. He told me that it would be all covered under the warranty, because they could not find any reason why the block cracked. Fast forward to just before Thanksgiving, i call and ask if my truck would be done before the holiday so i could go see my family for the holiday. Leo, tells me that the engine is assembled and ready to go back into the truck, however, they are short staffed and more than likely it will not be done. But should be done before the end of the month. Around Dec 4th, still haven't hear anything so i try calling Leo again, no response for a couple days. Then finally someone answers the phone, and tells me that Leo is no longer with the company and that my original salesman would be handling this.
Now this is where it goes really side ways
Joe (salesman) tells me that my engine is completely torn apart and that they are trying to figure out what happened. He sends me a few pictures of the damages, a facetime call with the service manager viewing the engine pieces. And things are just not lining up with what Cass (owner of Choates) is telling. Cass is trying to convince me that a bolt was dropped into the timing cavity during installation. Sat there for 40,000 miles before working loose and finding its way into the timing gears. So i ask, did you find the bolt or pieces of a bolt in the oil pan? He tells e that all they found were tiny metal shavings an they could identify where they cam from. but he knows this is what happened, but cannot prove it.

I do want to note that there are no nicks or marks on the block or the timing cover at all, they look as they were made. So i cannot believe something went through the timing gears and evaporated into dust without leaving a mark no any other parts. The only damage was to the cam gear and the crank timing gear (attached pictures). And since Cass "believes" or "knows", they are refusing to cover it under warranty. And are trying to hit me for +$11k in repair costs. I have spoke with several engine builders and they all say the same thing that if they cannot prove their theory, they should cover it under the warranty. One guy even said that just because someone believes it to be true, doesn't make it so in a court room.

What do you guys think? Ask any questions i have all the details, its just alot to type out.


smith cam gear.jpg
1920x300 smith crank gear.jpg
 
Joined
Feb 22, 2022
Messages
46
Reaction score
5
Location
Missouri
Yeah so funny story. I have never had any social media pages. And I tried to sign up for Facebook a week ago. But I have such a generic name, they kept flagging me, suspending me, and then disabling my account. Literally within minutes of getting it setup, on 3 occasions.
 

mikeyparrino726

New member
Joined
Jan 3, 2023
Messages
16
Reaction score
5
Location
New Jersey
Never ever waste your time with that junk company, all they care about is their money, they don't give a shit about the customer. Heard, read, and seen way too many bad things about them.
 

mikeyparrino726

New member
Joined
Jan 3, 2023
Messages
16
Reaction score
5
Location
New Jersey
So just their reputation that kept you away from them? Or did you have a direct experience?
Well theres two reasons why I would PERSONALLY never use them. First reason being I can build my own motor that will be 10 times better than theirs lol. Second reason is I have heard too many bad stories about them and their engines not holding up to the abuse they SHOULD be able to take, plus weird warranty claims. And last reason is that there is so many better places to get a motor, our shop builds a stout 6.4, my boss is extremely smart and experienced with 6.4s. Or if you want to have a motor from a big name type shop you can always hit midwest diesel, kill devil, rcd, beech, I mean the options are endless. I wouldn't even use Choate if they were the last people building 6.4 engines, I would simply move on to a different platform (and thats coming from an absolutely die hard 6.4 owner)
 
Joined
Feb 22, 2022
Messages
46
Reaction score
5
Location
Missouri
I’m at that point also. I love the truck so either it is Cummins time (fummins) or 6.7 trade up time. What company do you work for?
 

mikeyparrino726

New member
Joined
Jan 3, 2023
Messages
16
Reaction score
5
Location
New Jersey
I’m at that point also. I love the truck so either it is Cummins time (fummins) or 6.7 trade up time. What company do you work for?

I work for a shop called Jersey Diesel Performance. We are in Farmingdale NJ. I am the shop manager and assist my boss in most engine builds. Don’t waste your time or money on a cummins swap. Let a good place build you a good 6.4 motor! 6.4 engines are one of the best diesels when built correctly. They tow great, make good power, great fuel economy, they are just all around stout trucks once you build a proper engine


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

mikeyparrino726

New member
Joined
Jan 3, 2023
Messages
16
Reaction score
5
Location
New Jersey
What is your build recommendation? This one made 550hp on a tow tune with stock fueling

My honest to god recommendation is just maxxforce 7 pistons with head studs. your choice as to how you want to hone the cylinders and cut the pistons and stuff. But, If you did maxxforce pistons with arp studs and oringed heads with a s366 single, fass 165, crank case vent, weight loss, all the mishimoto coolers, and a street tune. you will probably have a 300,000 mile truck. By doing all of those things you basically solve all the 6.4’s short comings, maybe throw s&b cab mounts on the list too


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Joined
Feb 22, 2022
Messages
46
Reaction score
5
Location
Missouri
This one had maxxforce pistons (coated, delipped, and flycut), o-ringed heads and arp studs, comp cams stage 2 cam with valve springs, 3/8” chromoly pushrods, odawg manifold, afm blade runner turbo’s, no limit cold side pipe, mprb stainless up pipes, csf alum intercooler. And I have a water/meth kit on the shelf if I ever get my truck back.
 

mikeyparrino726

New member
Joined
Jan 3, 2023
Messages
16
Reaction score
5
Location
New Jersey
This one had maxxforce pistons (coated, delipped, and flycut), o-ringed heads and arp studs, comp cams stage 2 cam with valve springs, 3/8” chromoly pushrods, odawg manifold, afm blade runner turbo’s, no limit cold side pipe, mprb stainless up pipes, csf alum intercooler. And I have a water/meth kit on the shelf if I ever get my truck back.

thats junk


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

mikeyparrino726

New member
Joined
Jan 3, 2023
Messages
16
Reaction score
5
Location
New Jersey
Give me a call if you want me to explain everything. I don’t mean to come off so stern but I have a working method developing. 7324840209
 

sootie

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 3, 2012
Messages
11,854
Reaction score
29
lol @ 300k six four.....and that HD pistons and head studs are all you need haha

dont drink the kool aid, folks...

Its like 2011 all over again
 

Latest posts

Top