Guys that tow long haul: AC or windows?

Which one do you use?

  • I use AC, and notice NO decrease in MPG

    Votes: 21 80.8%
  • I use windows, and notice no decrease in MPG.

    Votes: 1 3.8%
  • I use AC, and notice a loss in MPG

    Votes: 1 3.8%
  • I use windows, and notice no MPG loss

    Votes: 3 11.5%

  • Total voters
    26

always-strokin

New member
Joined
May 18, 2013
Messages
672
Reaction score
0
^Good deal. I think I'm gonna give it a try (using the ac) and quit being a cheap, uncomfortable asshole when towing long.
 

bluedge8

Active member
Joined
May 18, 2011
Messages
3,879
Reaction score
0
Location
Champlin MN
my cousin used to drive courier locally, owned his own truck, early 2000's chevy 1/2t 2wd, 4.8L v8 and he used to drive all the time windows down to save money, then finally checked mileage when he started using the a/c- mileage went up 2mpg on average.
 

taterthedog

Active member
Joined
Jul 3, 2011
Messages
1,963
Reaction score
0
Location
Canada
Yea because the air tools, impacts, and nailguns wont.make.me.deaf anyway.

Already got the beginnings of occupational hearing loss. Anything loud now, I use earplugs. Keep them under my hard hat. Don't need it getting any worse.
 

Cknox121

New member
Joined
Apr 26, 2013
Messages
1,748
Reaction score
0
Location
Augusta GA
Highway speed windows up and ac on is the way to go mpg's

In town stop and go windows down

This is what the conclusion from mythbusters came to iirc


Sent from my cracked iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Grizzdog

New member
Joined
Sep 29, 2011
Messages
192
Reaction score
0
Your driving a 6 to 8000 pound truck. ..

Buy a car if you're worried about fuel economy

Nothing like a nice cool night in texas out in the country, windows down country blasting and a couple of beers.

Life is to short to worry about minor details like windows up or down.
 

Cknox121

New member
Joined
Apr 26, 2013
Messages
1,748
Reaction score
0
Location
Augusta GA
Your driving a 6 to 8000 pound truck. ..

Buy a car if you're worried about fuel economy

Nothing like a nice cool night in texas out in the country, windows down country blasting and a couple of beers.

Life is to short to worry about minor details like windows up or down.

This!!!


Sent from my cracked iPhone using Tapatalk
 

skobiak

New member
Joined
Nov 7, 2011
Messages
197
Reaction score
0
Location
Alberta, Canada
Seriously? Does that post make sense to you? Not sure what you are trying to say. I've read it a few times thinking I missed something, but nope, its not me. (regarding post #30, forgot to quote)
 

Powerstroke Cowboy

Well-known member
Joined
May 20, 2011
Messages
4,386
Reaction score
156
Location
Montana
Seriously? Does that post make sense to you? Not sure what you are trying to say. I've read it a few times thinking I missed something, but nope, its not me. (regarding post #30, forgot to quote)

Yes sir make sense to me. I guess that is because I wrote it.
 

Lethalthreat7.3

New member
Joined
Mar 24, 2013
Messages
313
Reaction score
0
Location
Denver, CO
Useage of the a.c compressor happens more than when it is set to "a.c". The a.c is used to dehumidify when the vehicle is put in defrost. Try turning the defrost on and you will hear the clutch cycle on/off.
Horsepower usage is dependent on load and can range from approx 2hp-20hp. Load is dependent on compressor displacement, cab temp and outside air temp.
Refrigerant absorbs the cab interior heat and is rejected by the condenser. A.C does NOT blow cold air. The refrigerant flowing through the evaporator absorbs the heat from the air inside the cab and is carried outside of the cab and rejected.
An A.C system works like this:
The compressor compresses refrigerant vapor. Compressing makes heat so the refrigerant is a hot gas leaving the compressor in route to the condenser. As air flows through the condenser the refrigerant condenses from a HOT VAPOR to a HOT LIQUID. The hot liquid refrigerant travels from the condenser to the accumulator. The accumulator is a reservoir for the hot liquid to accumulate and assure that a full liquid is available to allow the change of state to a COLD LIQUID. The refrigerant's change of state occurs when the HOT LIQUID is forced through the metering device, capillary tube or txv(thermo-expansion valve). The COLD LIQUID fills and flows through the evaporator and absorbs the heat in the cab. As heat is absorbed in the evaporator it causes the refrigerant to change state to a COLD VAPOR. The last coil pass is where the COLD LIQUID TO COLD VAPOR state change occurs and is critical on the proper efficiency and a.c operation. Too little refrigerant and the evap will not be flooded, poor cooling(absorption) in the cab as well as to the compressor. Too much refrigerant and "slugging" will occur, you can't compress liquid.
I needed to explain the cycle so that the "load" can be understood.
When the cab is say 100*, O.A is 90* and the vehicle is just idling or has minimal airflow pressures can be over 300+psig discharge/48+psig return. Hp usage can be close to 20. With the cab at say 70*, O.A still at 90* but cruising at say 75 the pressures can be 225/35 and a much shorter cycle/on time and longer "off" time. The compressor cycles on/off via the low pressure switch, lower load=shorter cycle. Not only is the cycle shorter but the load requires less hp because the pressures are lower. The hp required can be as low as 10% at approx 2hp.
Rejecting the heat is extremely critical. Not only does the efficiency drop but pressures obviously rise and component life is shortened from bent fins and bugs in the condenser. The condenser is first in the barrage of objects blowing through the grill, then the intercooler and radiator. You very rarely if ever can see a temperature rise in the vehicles coolant but install a set of gauges on the a.c and you can see over a 50+psig rise on the discharge, load=fuel.
The #1 reason for A.C failures in residential and commercial systems is HEAT!( Yes bad power(brown-outs, surges and single phasing) is #2). Most residential compressor failures(if the system is initially installed correctly) are caused by heat due to the condenser being plugged full of grass, leaves and dirt. Not only can you help prevent component failures but you can save up to approx 25% on your utility bill by cleaning the condenser out every time you mow the grass. You can save 3% to 7% for every degree you lower the thermostat.
Keeping the fins straight and debris/bugs out of the condenser does the same for a vehicles a.c efficiency.
Running down the road at highway speeds with the windows down does cause a large aerodynamic drag and does cost more in fuel mileage.
If you want to know approx hp needed to operate your various components, a.c, alternator, ect..., manufacturers will usually list the wattage required to power the component. Divide the wattage required by 745.7 to obtain the hp requirement.
Example for alternator. Amps x Volts = Watts. 100a x 14.2v = 1419.999w =1.902hp. So 1420 watts requires approx 2hp. This is however a formula and pulley size, bearing wear, belts, tensioner and anything else that causes unforeseen drag can change this.
Personally, 2hp or even 5hp does not make a difference on a large diesel motor and is very minimal on smaller ones.
Gas engines are different when your little chipmunks are screaming to give you the 150hp they are supposedly rated for using the large hill and tail wind. Lol. One of my boy's econo-cars almost feels like a tiny nos shot when the a.c is shutoff under wot. Turn it back on and I swear a parachute was released. LOL!
 

always-strokin

New member
Joined
May 18, 2013
Messages
672
Reaction score
0
Your driving a 6 to 8000 pound truck. ..

Buy a car if you're worried about fuel economy

Nothing like a nice cool night in texas out in the country, windows down country blasting and a couple of beers.

Life is to short to worry about minor details like windows up or down.

Because when you drive several thousand miles at a time, a few "measly" mpg equates to several hundred or several thousand dollars more in fuel costs. Why do you think tractor trailers advertise getting 1mpg or 2mpg more than its competition?

Useage of the a.c compressor happens more than when it is set to "a.c". The a.c is used to dehumidify when the vehicle is put in defrost. Try turning the defrost on and you will hear the clutch cycle on/off.
Horsepower usage is dependent on load and can range from approx 2hp-20hp. Load is dependent on compressor displacement, cab temp and outside air temp.
Refrigerant absorbs the cab interior heat and is rejected by the condenser. A.C does NOT blow cold air. The refrigerant flowing through the evaporator absorbs the heat from the air inside the cab and is carried outside of the cab and rejected.
An A.C system works like this:
The compressor compresses refrigerant vapor. Compressing makes heat so the refrigerant is a hot gas leaving the compressor in route to the condenser. As air flows through the condenser the refrigerant condenses from a HOT VAPOR to a HOT LIQUID. The hot liquid refrigerant travels from the condenser to the accumulator. The accumulator is a reservoir for the hot liquid to accumulate and assure that a full liquid is available to allow the change of state to a COLD LIQUID. The refrigerant's change of state occurs when the HOT LIQUID is forced through the metering device, capillary tube or txv(thermo-expansion valve). The COLD LIQUID fills and flows through the evaporator and absorbs the heat in the cab. As heat is absorbed in the evaporator it causes the refrigerant to change state to a COLD VAPOR. The last coil pass is where the COLD LIQUID TO COLD VAPOR state change occurs and is critical on the proper efficiency and a.c operation. Too little refrigerant and the evap will not be flooded, poor cooling(absorption) in the cab as well as to the compressor. Too much refrigerant and "slugging" will occur, you can't compress liquid.
I needed to explain the cycle so that the "load" can be understood.
When the cab is say 100*, O.A is 90* and the vehicle is just idling or has minimal airflow pressures can be over 300+psig discharge/48+psig return. Hp usage can be close to 20. With the cab at say 70*, O.A still at 90* but cruising at say 75 the pressures can be 225/35 and a much shorter cycle/on time and longer "off" time. The compressor cycles on/off via the low pressure switch, lower load=shorter cycle. Not only is the cycle shorter but the load requires less hp because the pressures are lower. The hp required can be as low as 10% at approx 2hp.
Rejecting the heat is extremely critical. Not only does the efficiency drop but pressures obviously rise and component life is shortened from bent fins and bugs in the condenser. The condenser is first in the barrage of objects blowing through the grill, then the intercooler and radiator. You very rarely if ever can see a temperature rise in the vehicles coolant but install a set of gauges on the a.c and you can see over a 50+psig rise on the discharge, load=fuel.
The #1 reason for A.C failures in residential and commercial systems is HEAT!( Yes bad power(brown-outs, surges and single phasing) is #2). Most residential compressor failures(if the system is initially installed correctly) are caused by heat due to the condenser being plugged full of grass, leaves and dirt. Not only can you help prevent component failures but you can save up to approx 25% on your utility bill by cleaning the condenser out every time you mow the grass. You can save 3% to 7% for every degree you lower the thermostat.
Keeping the fins straight and debris/bugs out of the condenser does the same for a vehicles a.c efficiency.
Running down the road at highway speeds with the windows down does cause a large aerodynamic drag and does cost more in fuel mileage.
If you want to know approx hp needed to operate your various components, a.c, alternator, ect..., manufacturers will usually list the wattage required to power the component. Divide the wattage required by 745.7 to obtain the hp requirement.
Example for alternator. Amps x Volts = Watts. 100a x 14.2v = 1419.999w =1.902hp. So 1420 watts requires approx 2hp. This is however a formula and pulley size, bearing wear, belts, tensioner and anything else that causes unforeseen drag can change this.
Personally, 2hp or even 5hp does not make a difference on a large diesel motor and is very minimal on smaller ones.
Gas engines are different when your little chipmunks are screaming to give you the 150hp they are supposedly rated for using the large hill and tail wind. Lol. One of my boy's econo-cars almost feels like a tiny nos shot when the a.c is shutoff under wot. Turn it back on and I swear a parachute was released. LOL!

Holy-information, Batman! Appreciate the education bud.
 

bluedge8

Active member
Joined
May 18, 2011
Messages
3,879
Reaction score
0
Location
Champlin MN
^Even on LOCAL delivery he gained 2mpg???????
yes and no, in the mpls/ st. paul area a lot of his driving would have been on city hwy's and freeways, but of course he was in stop and go situations as well, and the increase was going from not using air to using it, so the type of driving varied but was not different from before air to after air, make sense?
This. Windows up ac wide open no matter what. I try not to ever roll my windows down.
me too, except my beater work vehicles air doesn't work right now, and I can't decide if I should spend any money on a/c on a old car that has 300k on it LOL

Useage of the a.c compressor happens more than when it is set to "a.c". The a.c is used to dehumidify when the vehicle is put in defrost. Try turning the defrost on and you will hear the clutch cycle on/off.
Horsepower usage is dependent on load and can range from approx 2hp-20hp. Load is dependent on compressor displacement, cab temp and outside air temp.
Refrigerant absorbs the cab interior heat and is rejected by the condenser. A.C does NOT blow cold air. The refrigerant flowing through the evaporator absorbs the heat from the air inside the cab and is carried outside of the cab and rejected.
An A.C system works like this:
The compressor compresses refrigerant vapor. Compressing makes heat so the refrigerant is a hot gas leaving the compressor in route to the condenser. As air flows through the condenser the refrigerant condenses from a HOT VAPOR to a HOT LIQUID. The hot liquid refrigerant travels from the condenser to the accumulator. The accumulator is a reservoir for the hot liquid to accumulate and assure that a full liquid is available to allow the change of state to a COLD LIQUID. The refrigerant's change of state occurs when the HOT LIQUID is forced through the metering device, capillary tube or txv(thermo-expansion valve). The COLD LIQUID fills and flows through the evaporator and absorbs the heat in the cab. As heat is absorbed in the evaporator it causes the refrigerant to change state to a COLD VAPOR. The last coil pass is where the COLD LIQUID TO COLD VAPOR state change occurs and is critical on the proper efficiency and a.c operation. Too little refrigerant and the evap will not be flooded, poor cooling(absorption) in the cab as well as to the compressor. Too much refrigerant and "slugging" will occur, you can't compress liquid.
I needed to explain the cycle so that the "load" can be understood.
When the cab is say 100*, O.A is 90* and the vehicle is just idling or has minimal airflow pressures can be over 300+psig discharge/48+psig return. Hp usage can be close to 20. With the cab at say 70*, O.A still at 90* but cruising at say 75 the pressures can be 225/35 and a much shorter cycle/on time and longer "off" time. The compressor cycles on/off via the low pressure switch, lower load=shorter cycle. Not only is the cycle shorter but the load requires less hp because the pressures are lower. The hp required can be as low as 10% at approx 2hp.
Rejecting the heat is extremely critical. Not only does the efficiency drop but pressures obviously rise and component life is shortened from bent fins and bugs in the condenser. The condenser is first in the barrage of objects blowing through the grill, then the intercooler and radiator. You very rarely if ever can see a temperature rise in the vehicles coolant but install a set of gauges on the a.c and you can see over a 50+psig rise on the discharge, load=fuel.
The #1 reason for A.C failures in residential and commercial systems is HEAT!( Yes bad power(brown-outs, surges and single phasing) is #2). Most residential compressor failures(if the system is initially installed correctly) are caused by heat due to the condenser being plugged full of grass, leaves and dirt. Not only can you help prevent component failures but you can save up to approx 25% on your utility bill by cleaning the condenser out every time you mow the grass. You can save 3% to 7% for every degree you lower the thermostat.
Keeping the fins straight and debris/bugs out of the condenser does the same for a vehicles a.c efficiency.
Running down the road at highway speeds with the windows down does cause a large aerodynamic drag and does cost more in fuel mileage.
If you want to know approx hp needed to operate your various components, a.c, alternator, ect..., manufacturers will usually list the wattage required to power the component. Divide the wattage required by 745.7 to obtain the hp requirement.
Example for alternator. Amps x Volts = Watts. 100a x 14.2v = 1419.999w =1.902hp. So 1420 watts requires approx 2hp. This is however a formula and pulley size, bearing wear, belts, tensioner and anything else that causes unforeseen drag can change this.
Personally, 2hp or even 5hp does not make a difference on a large diesel motor and is very minimal on smaller ones.
Gas engines are different when your little chipmunks are screaming to give you the 150hp they are supposedly rated for using the large hill and tail wind. Lol. One of my boy's econo-cars almost feels like a tiny nos shot when the a.c is shutoff under wot. Turn it back on and I swear a parachute was released. LOL!
woah,, do we have a Charles number 2 in the making?? LOL LOL LOL
just kidding bud, was actually a very good read, thanks for that.
 

TyCorr

New member
Joined
Jun 23, 2011
Messages
15,461
Reaction score
0
This!!!


Sent from my cracked iPhone using Tapatalk

What the hell does riding around drinking in a vehicle at night while in Texas have to do with running your ac when pulling at highway speeds?

Im confused, since we're discussing economy. Nobody gives a **** if a prius gets better mileage. I have a 300hp car with a v8 that gets 25mpg if its cruising. I still care, to some degree, what level of economy the truck achieves.
 

Latest posts

Members online

Top