HeavyAssault
Active member
I give a chunk about more power (1-2 MAYBE) at a cost of $600. What matters is the life of the injector and how to keep it happy.
Anybody with regulated fuel return read this!
- Thread starter madpowerstroke
- Start date
strokin6L
Active member
I'd like to see others hit the dyno as well just to see....not just one truck. Maybe others will dyno soon to confirm what Renae had seen with his truck on the dyno.
HeavyAssault
Active member
Okay I'll play...Where are the dyno sheets, the videos, the track time slips???
WTF another hour I'll never get back.
WTF another hour I'll never get back.
To test a change, sure.
HeavyAssault
Active member
Oh that will go well. All the peeps posting up that the dyno wasnt loaded, the dyno used is junk, BLAH BLAH BLAH.....same soup, different bowl.
strokin6L
Active member
yes as long as you use the same dyno/operator. I was just stating that just because the dyno said your truck put down X amount of power...doesn't always mean that your truck has that X amount of power.
Charles
Well-known member
- Joined
- May 18, 2011
- Messages
- 2,711
- Reaction score
- 27
Is there some kind of decoder, or auto-translate feature for this member that I'm simply not using correctly?
HeavyAssault
Active member
Everyone else is posting up dynos results have shown an increase in power. Where is the info?? I guess I don't have the dyno sheet reader app from PSA installed.
Black_Lightning91
New member
- Joined
- Sep 29, 2011
- Messages
- 98
- Reaction score
- 0
So since no one has even attempted to explain whats going on I will. I use the Scientific method for all my problem solving because it works. So first lets cover what we know about the situation.
First a regulated return will maintain set pressure from its location in the return back to the pump because it creates a restriction. We know there are probably 5-10psi worth of pressure drop across filters, lines, rails before it gets to the regulated return so pressure at the pump must be greater than what the regulator see's.
Now we got people lowering supply set pressure and seeing gains in throttle responce smoke output and lower egt's. A pressure difference of 5-15 psi (45 min to 60 max) is meaningless because that pressure is increased to tens of thousands of psi inside the injector. So long as it has enough psi to quickly fill the injector with fuel it should have no other effect.
So how is lowering this pressure causing an effect. Well anytime you create pressure you create HEAT (no one mentioned this). So lets look at heat in the fuel system. Pump generating flow against a restiction creates pressure and heat. this heat moves through the fuel system gaining more heat from injectors rails ect till it goes back to tank. Now if a regulated return is set to 60 psi it will remain closed much more than if @ 45 psi meaning more of the heat the fuel picked up stays in the system and continues to build and less is allowed to return with the fuel to the tank to be dissipated.
The injectors however heat the fuel much more when creating injection pressure so how could heat cause this. Well heat before the injector has a large effect on fuel DENSITY. The density of the fuel before the injector actually changes how much fuel the injector can produce per stroke.
Another thing think of air flow, density and temp in a forced induction system. If the compressor is forced out of its map or happy place by the pressure(increases density) it must produce it starts to generate more heat(lowers density) than actual flow which actually causes a density loss despite what pressure its at.
Okay few more pieces we know, after an orifice (fixed or varible) there is a pressure drop. When there is pressure drop there is a cooling effect (principle that AC systems work on) and heat is lessoned. The factory setup had the regulator pre-rails, it returned lots of fuel(and heat) to tank and created a pressure drop before rails also lessening heat in the fuel to the injectors. Seems to me they knew an importance of heat in the fuel pre-rails causing lowered density.
Now lets add all this together to give my hypothesis, In a regulated return fuel system the heat built up in the fuel from generating pressure and other outside heat sources causes a change in the specific density of the fuel. This is further compounded in higher psi systems because the orifice is closed more meaning less hot fuel return to tank which in turn carries this latent heat with it. Lowing the desired pressure allows for more return flow removing more heat and increasing the density of the fuel in the supply rails. This would explain the results we are seeing.
Now to test this. Measureing fuel temp and psi at (pump, Pre-rails(close as possible for accuracy) and after the regulator) we can varify a difference in temp in the system from lowering and raising the regulator set psi. Now with this data looking at the tempurature difference at the rails we can mathmatically figure the density of the fuel with regulator at x and y psi. This data can be used to guess an amount of hp increase or decrease based on density and this can be verified on a dyno by setting x psi measure and y psi measure then compare to your math.
Well hopefully that sums up what I think is going on here and gives a rational way for someone to test this. Since I don't even got a diesel powered anything atm that is left up to you guys.
Another thing to further test this one could add a fuel cooler pre supply rails and further cool the fuel and see what effect that has. I believe it was said best above that the system must be designed to work in harmony throughout. Judging by no one even saying anything about temps and latent heat ect I'm assuming this is the over looked part and the key to this problem. A regulated return is a great thing for making sure the injectors see the right amount of fuel and dont starve but I think over looking heat & density and an abilty to cool fuel pre rails like the factory set-up does through multiple ways is the down fall to current RR set-ups. If someone wanted to measure psi and temp pre supply rails on a completely stock well maintained setup it would be great to compare with out RR measurements from pre rails to see the diffence in what IH Pressure/heat to our RR pressure and heat. Good day and sorry if its long winded but I just woke up lol
First a regulated return will maintain set pressure from its location in the return back to the pump because it creates a restriction. We know there are probably 5-10psi worth of pressure drop across filters, lines, rails before it gets to the regulated return so pressure at the pump must be greater than what the regulator see's.
Now we got people lowering supply set pressure and seeing gains in throttle responce smoke output and lower egt's. A pressure difference of 5-15 psi (45 min to 60 max) is meaningless because that pressure is increased to tens of thousands of psi inside the injector. So long as it has enough psi to quickly fill the injector with fuel it should have no other effect.
So how is lowering this pressure causing an effect. Well anytime you create pressure you create HEAT (no one mentioned this). So lets look at heat in the fuel system. Pump generating flow against a restiction creates pressure and heat. this heat moves through the fuel system gaining more heat from injectors rails ect till it goes back to tank. Now if a regulated return is set to 60 psi it will remain closed much more than if @ 45 psi meaning more of the heat the fuel picked up stays in the system and continues to build and less is allowed to return with the fuel to the tank to be dissipated.
The injectors however heat the fuel much more when creating injection pressure so how could heat cause this. Well heat before the injector has a large effect on fuel DENSITY. The density of the fuel before the injector actually changes how much fuel the injector can produce per stroke.
Another thing think of air flow, density and temp in a forced induction system. If the compressor is forced out of its map or happy place by the pressure(increases density) it must produce it starts to generate more heat(lowers density) than actual flow which actually causes a density loss despite what pressure its at.
Okay few more pieces we know, after an orifice (fixed or varible) there is a pressure drop. When there is pressure drop there is a cooling effect (principle that AC systems work on) and heat is lessoned. The factory setup had the regulator pre-rails, it returned lots of fuel(and heat) to tank and created a pressure drop before rails also lessening heat in the fuel to the injectors. Seems to me they knew an importance of heat in the fuel pre-rails causing lowered density.
Now lets add all this together to give my hypothesis, In a regulated return fuel system the heat built up in the fuel from generating pressure and other outside heat sources causes a change in the specific density of the fuel. This is further compounded in higher psi systems because the orifice is closed more meaning less hot fuel return to tank which in turn carries this latent heat with it. Lowing the desired pressure allows for more return flow removing more heat and increasing the density of the fuel in the supply rails. This would explain the results we are seeing.
Now to test this. Measureing fuel temp and psi at (pump, Pre-rails(close as possible for accuracy) and after the regulator) we can varify a difference in temp in the system from lowering and raising the regulator set psi. Now with this data looking at the tempurature difference at the rails we can mathmatically figure the density of the fuel with regulator at x and y psi. This data can be used to guess an amount of hp increase or decrease based on density and this can be verified on a dyno by setting x psi measure and y psi measure then compare to your math.
Well hopefully that sums up what I think is going on here and gives a rational way for someone to test this. Since I don't even got a diesel powered anything atm that is left up to you guys.
Another thing to further test this one could add a fuel cooler pre supply rails and further cool the fuel and see what effect that has. I believe it was said best above that the system must be designed to work in harmony throughout. Judging by no one even saying anything about temps and latent heat ect I'm assuming this is the over looked part and the key to this problem. A regulated return is a great thing for making sure the injectors see the right amount of fuel and dont starve but I think over looking heat & density and an abilty to cool fuel pre rails like the factory set-up does through multiple ways is the down fall to current RR set-ups. If someone wanted to measure psi and temp pre supply rails on a completely stock well maintained setup it would be great to compare with out RR measurements from pre rails to see the diffence in what IH Pressure/heat to our RR pressure and heat. Good day and sorry if its long winded but I just woke up lol
Last edited:
Well that went way over your head.
I agree but the number given shouldn't matter, just the differences between the runs.
Charles
Well-known member
- Joined
- May 18, 2011
- Messages
- 2,711
- Reaction score
- 27
If you can't strap a truck down and make a pull at 40, 50, 60 and 70 psi, then 70, 60, 50, 40psi for a control, then just stay where you're at and someone will be along shortly and beat you to death with a tack hammer, because you are a retard.
Seriously.
Accuracy does NOT matter here, only precision.
Seriously.
Accuracy does NOT matter here, only precision.
Last edited:
HeavyAssault
Active member
I'm smarter than you.
SO if the heat created through the RR system is causing the problem then why not return the fuel PRIOR to entering the system??
SO if the heat created through the RR system is causing the problem then why not return the fuel PRIOR to entering the system??
Black_Lightning91
New member
- Joined
- Sep 29, 2011
- Messages
- 98
- Reaction score
- 0
Oh sweet Charles is here, Charles please read my above post and critic it. I believe thats a post you would like in this thread! Any suggestions or corrections are welcome and thanks. P.S. I am still doing lots of research on compound charging and got some cool results thanks to your imput!
HeavyAssault
Active member
No one is here yet with that hammer.....Need directions??? Or do you need to ask momma to come out to play??
Charles
Well-known member
- Joined
- May 18, 2011
- Messages
- 2,711
- Reaction score
- 27
My eyes refuse to read it due to lack of formatting. I even went back and tried again and balked a second time.
Black_Lightning91
New member
- Joined
- Sep 29, 2011
- Messages
- 98
- Reaction score
- 0
WTF does that mean? It's about density changes caused by heat. Returning the fuel before the area where density matters (supply rails) is what the stock system does and is part of the reason we have a regulated return was because it returned to much starving the injectors. Returning fuel before the injectors will just mean less fuel to cool the injectors and remove the heat in that key point of the system. Im saying to cool the fuel pre supply rails as much as possible and allow for a lower set regulator psi which results in more flow to the take and more heat taken to the tank. IDK what your thinking but your ego I'm smarter comment leads me to believe your not.
Black_Lightning91
New member
- Joined
- Sep 29, 2011
- Messages
- 98
- Reaction score
- 0
I applogise for that i just woke up and really don't have a lot of time for somethign that in no way effects my busy life as I ain't got diesel at all right now. It is formatted to provide some information relating to topic then string this info together to form a hypothesis and then provides a method to test at the end. roughly its fast rough and to the point and basically in words the best i can do to describe how my mind worked it out.
I understand what you mean and its okay you don't have to read it just need someone to test it that proves it with data
Went back and added spaces so I think you can read it now!
Last edited:
HeavyAssault
Active member
OH now I have an ego. Trust me it's those other guys who demand dyno runs and track slips before they believe anything that have the EGO issues.
So oil doesn't cool the injectors??
So oil doesn't cool the injectors??
SSpeeDEMONSS
New member
so all i get from this thread is that some say more psi is better, others say more psi is better, and there is no factual data to prove either way. ok, got it.
Garrett
Garrett
Black_Lightning91
New member
- Joined
- Sep 29, 2011
- Messages
- 98
- Reaction score
- 0
You said I'm smarter than you which is an ego no matter how small. I agree just about everyone on here has ego issues in different amounts, but this is irrelevant to the topic.
Yes oil cools the injector but so does the fuel. It's not so much about cooling the injector as it is the heat built in the FUEL system before the injector lowers the density of the fuel creating these issues.
Last edited:
